The Network Effect

People handle adversity differently; some break down sooner than others. When a team focused on a common goal faces adverse conditions, dissent among some team members precludes them from reaching a shared goal. Under extreme conditions, a mutiny isn’t just mission-critical—it can leave everybody dead. The famous explorer Ernest Shackleton, best remembered for his Antarctic expedition of 1914–1916 in the ship Endurance, managed such risks by assigning the whiny, complaining crew members to sleep in his own tent and share the chores with him. Clustering the “complainers” with him minimized their negative influence on others, and this helped his team survive and accomplish their goals.

Medicare Vs. Private Payers

It’s essential to acknowledge the contrasting dynamics between Medicare and private payers. Medicare, as a government-backed program, follows distinct regulations and reimbursement structures, while private payers operate in a competitive market with more flexible terms. The negotiation strategies and considerations may differ significantly when dealing with these two payer types.

Payment negotiations

Actively negotiating with payers is crucial for independent medical practices. However, many providers lack experience or haven’t been successful in past negotiations due to inadequate preparation. To ensure a fruitful negotiation, it’s vital to:

  • Know Your Data: Understand your practice-specific data, including patient volume, charges, reimbursement history, and more.
  • Know the Terms of Each Contract: Familiarize yourself with your current payer-specific contract terms, especially the reimbursement schedule and the claims filing data. (Babcock, 2021)

According to a KFF analysis, as seen in the image below, private insurers often pay nearly double the Medicare rates for hospital services. Specifically, for outpatient hospital services, private insurance rates were found to be significantly higher than Medicare rates, averaging 264% of the latter. This difference underscores the varying dynamics and market powers between Medicare and private insurers. Policymakers and analysts continue to debate the necessity of high payments from private payers to compensate for the lower Medicare payments. (How Much More Than Medicare Do Private Insurers Pay? A Review of the Literature | KFF, 2020)

Classification of Payment Models

Payment models dictate how healthcare providers, including physicians and hospitals, are remunerated for their services. Each model inherently carries incentives and disincentives that can influence the balance between cost reduction and improving care quality. These two objectives often stand at odds. This report delves into the implications of Alternative Payment Models (APMs) in either mitigating or intensifying health disparities. However, before exploring these implications, it’s essential to understand the incentives and disincentives embedded within the prevailing payment models. These incentives play a pivotal role in fostering cost-efficient, high-quality care.

The primary distinction among these payment methods lies in the unit of payment. This determines how financial risk is distributed between the payer and the provider. The nature of this risk can significantly influence the behavior of healthcare providers and the overall efficiency and effectiveness of the healthcare system (Quinn, 2015).

Factors affecting payment negotiations

According to AMA, it’s not just about the rates but also about the terms and conditions that can impact payment. For instance, some contracts might have clauses that allow payers to change rates without notice, or they might have stringent requirements for prior authorizations. Providers should be wary of “most favored nation” clauses, which can restrict them from offering better rates to other payers. It’s also crucial to be aware of the dispute resolution process outlined in the contract, should any disagreements arise. By being well-prepared and understanding the intricacies of payer contracts, providers can position themselves for more favorable negotiations and better financial outcomes. (American Medical Association & American Medical Association, 2022)

Payer-provider conflict

In the payer-provider conflict, the providers who accept lower reimbursement and who don’t challenge underpayments or delayed payments make it easier for the payers to maintain their market control (oligopsony). Recent research supports this notion, indicating that payers with larger market shares have more negotiating power in contract negotiations (HealthPayer Intelligence).

ClinicMind’s network helps providers maintain their payment schedules and motivation by establishing a shared discipline for clients and billers alike in terms of both thought and action.

Payers with Larger Market Share and Their Negotiating Power

Payers that have a dominant presence in the local market have a distinct advantage when it comes to negotiating lower prices for physician office visits. A study conducted by researchers from Harvard Medical School found that health insurance companies with a market share of 15% or more negotiated visit prices that were 21% lower than those set by payers with a market share of 5% or less. For instance, payers with less than 5% of the market negotiated prices of $88 per office visit. In contrast, those with 5 to 15% of the market share settled for a price of $72, and those with more than 15% of the market share negotiated even lower at $70 per visit. The graph below shows this analysis.  

From Policy Changes to Physician Consolidation

In 2010, President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act (ACA) into law, a move that expanded Medicare’s reach by adding millions to its coverage. This expansion meant that more physicians had to accept Medicare rates, which have been systematically reduced over time. The ACA not only aimed to extend healthcare access to uninsured Americans but also set in motion a wave of consolidation in healthcare services.

As Medicare adjusted its rates, private insurance companies followed suit. While they still paid above Medicare rates, they too began to reduce their payouts. This trend forced physicians to grapple with a challenging reality: working more hours for less pay.

The Power of the Network Effect

In response to these financial pressures, physicians began to see the value in consolidating their practices. By joining larger organizations, they could harness the network effect, gaining more significant negotiating leverage with insurance companies. This consolidation is not just about survival; it’s about strength in numbers. Large groups, especially those with revenues exceeding $1 million annually, have more room to negotiate than smaller entities.

The Rise of Management Service Organizations (MSO)

Amidst these challenges, the MSO model emerged as a beacon for physicians seeking to modernize while retaining their independence. Backed by private equity, MSOs offer economies of scale, growth opportunities, and, in some cases, increased reimbursement rates. They present a win-win, allowing physicians to remain autonomous while benefiting from the resources and expertise of a larger organization.

Despite Medicare’s conservative fee updates, total Medicare spending on physician services per beneficiary grew by 60 percent from 2000 to 2009. This growth rate, averaging 5.4 percent annually, underscores the influence Medicare has on the broader healthcare landscape, prompting private insurers to recalibrate their payment structures. (Frakt & Frakt, 2014)

Physician Burnout and Time Allocation

A significant concern in the medical community is the increasing administrative burden on physicians. Reports suggest that doctors spend 27% of their time in their offices seeing patients and a staggering 49.2% on paperwork. This administrative overhead, coupled with reduced reimbursements, contributes to physician burnout and challenges in patient care.

The Medicare conversion factor (CF) is a scaling factor that converts the geographically adjusted number of relative value units (RVUs) for each service in the Medicare physician payment schedule (MFS) into a dollar payment amount.  The initial Medicare CF was set at $31.001 in 1992.  Until 2015, subsequent default or current law CF updates were determined largely by an expenditure target formula. In 2015, the Medicare Access and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) Reauthorization Act (MACRA) of 2015 permanently eliminated the existing expenditure target, ie, the sustainable growth rate (SGR), and replaced it with fixed updates that are specified in the legislation.

With the Medicare Conversion Factor decreasing by 9.9% over the years and inflation-adjusted payments to physicians effectively decreasing by 42%, the financial landscape for physicians remains challenging. The future demands vision, adaptability, and a keen understanding of both policy and market dynamics.

Good to Great by Jim Collins

In Good to Great, Jim Collins articulates a management methodology that’s based on a process of buildup followed by breakthrough. This can be broken into three broad stages, each driven by three key concepts:

  1. Disciplined people – Level 5 leadership, and “first who . . . then what”
  2. Disciplined thought–Confrontation of the brutal facts(yet without losing faith) and the “hedgehog” concept (simplicity within the “three circles”)
  3. Disciplined action–A culture of discipline and technology accelerators

Wrapping around this entire framework is a concept of “fly-wheel”—which, under disciplined people, thought, and action accumulates inertia and takes the company from good to great.

One concept in the Good to Great methodology is called The Stockdale Paradox. It’s named after Admiral Jim Stockdale, who was imprisoned in Vietnam and repeatedly tortured for over eight years. In a conversation with Collins, Stockdale described how he survived while so many died after just months in captivity:

“I never lost faith in the end of the story. I never doubted not only that I would get out, but also that I would prevail in the end and turn the experience into the defining event of my life, which, in retrospect, I would not trade.”

“Who didn’t make it out?” asked Collins.

“The optimists,” replied Stockdale. “They were the ones who said, ‘we’re going to be out by Christmas.’ And Christmas would come, and Christmas would go. Then they’d say, ‘We’re going to be out by Easter.’ And Easter would come, and Easter would go. And then Thanksgiving, and then it would be Christmas again. Then they died of a broken heart.

“You must never confuse faith that you will prevail in the end—which you can never afford to lose—with the discipline to confront the most brutal facts of your current reality, whatever they might be,” says Stockdale.(Puri, 2015)

Holding those two seemingly contradictory notions in his head simultaneously was the key to Stockdale survival. And it’s a perfect summary of the mindset you need to manage your office billing. You have to believe that you’ll be paid for your work. But you can never let your belief cloud your perception of reality: the payments to providers are costs for payers, whose objective is to improve profitability for their shareholders and, therefore, to reduce their payments to providers.

Claims are not paid by waiting for the payers to pay them. Claims are paid by payers who discover that delay and underpayment are more expensive than payment in full and on time (see Chapter 3). Without a system to make the payers pay, you’ll default to the payer’s system and find yourself giving up control.

Role of ClinicMind

ClinicMind is a system that can help make the payers pay—and it leverages the “network effect” to amplify its value. The network effect, according to Wikipedia, “causes a good or service to have a value to a potential customer which depends on the number of other customers who own the good or are users of the service.”(Wikipedia contributors, 2023b)

One consequence of a network effect is that the purchase of a service by one individual in- directly benefits others who also use the same service. For example, by purchasing a telephone, a person makes other telephones more useful. The resulting bandwagon effect is a positive feedback loop.

For ClicniMind, the network effect (also known as Metcalfe’s law) says that while ClinicMind’s costs are proportional to the number of submitted claims, the value of ClinicMind is proportional to the square of the number of practice owners using it. For example, if you multiply the number of ClinicMind users by 10, your systemwide cost goes up by a factor of 10, but the value goes up a hundredfold. In other words, Metcalfe’s law, as applied to ClinicMind, says that the value of ClinicMind to the individual practice owner is proportional to the number, n, of other practice owners who share the same billing knowledge base and processes. Now, multiply this value by the number of practice owners, and you have a value for the whole operation that’s roughly proportional to n2 .

In the early 1980s, when Robert Metcalfe discovered his law, he was vague about “value.” In those days, it had something to do with sharing expensive resources (like fax machines and printers), exchanging electronic mail, and accessing communications technologies (such as the Internet).The network effect offers several distinct advantages for physicians and their practices: 

  1. better reimbursement rates because of improved contract negotiation with payers, 
  2. improved collections because of better billing performance achieved by sharing a knowledge base across the network, collective insights, best practices, and strategies, leading to improved billing performance and reduced errors.
  3. lower audit risk because of fewer billing errors 
  4. efficient practice management, 
  5. accumulating purchasing economies: As practices come together, they can leverage their combined purchasing power to achieve cost savings. This can lead to reduced rates on essential expenses such as malpractice insurance and group healthcare costs.
  6. added revenue sources from integrated applications. 

And according to Metcalfe’s law, this value continues to grow, in step with each newly joined practice, long after you started using ClinicMind’s system.

The billing network allows the providers to consolidate their processing volumes and resources, matching the payer’s billing processing performance and controlling the billing process. 


The intricate dynamics of the healthcare industry, from the challenges of team cohesion during adversity to the complexities of payer-provider negotiations, underscore the importance of strategic management and informed decision-making. The story of Ernest Shackleton’s Antarctic expedition serves as a poignant reminder of the power of leadership and the necessity of mitigating negative influences. 

Similarly, the contrasting landscapes of Medicare and private payers highlight the need for healthcare providers to be well-versed in their negotiations and understand the intricacies of their contracts. The emergence of payment models and the associated risks and rewards further complicate this landscape. Amidst these challenges, the power of the network effect, as demonstrated by ClinicMind, offers a beacon of hope. 

By leveraging collective knowledge and shared resources, providers can amplify their negotiating power, streamline their operations, and ultimately deliver better patient care. As the healthcare landscape continues to evolve, staying informed, being proactive, and harnessing the power of networks will be paramount for success.


  1. Babcock, B. (2021, February 16). How Your Independent Practice Can Better Negotiate with Payers.
  2. How much more than Medicare do private insurers pay? A review of the literature | KFF. (2020, May 1). KFF.
  3. Edmiston, Kelly D. (2022). Alternative Payment Models, Value-Based Payments, and Health Disparities. Center for Insurance Policy & Research Report. National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
  4. Quinn, K. (2015, August 18). The 8 Basic Payment Methods in Health Care. Annals of Internal Medicine. 
  5. Puri, A. (2015). Good to Great by Jim Collins. 
  6. Wikipedia contributors. (2023b). Network effect. Wikipedia. 
  7. American Medical Association & American Medical Association. (2022, March 21). How value-based care is making payor contracts even more complex. American Medical Association. 
  8. Frakt, A., & Frakt, A. (2014, January 8). Physician services spending: Medicare vs. private insurers | The Incidental Economist. The Incidental Economist. 


A Future Book Publication Note:

This article is a chapter in the forthcoming 2nd Edition book “Medical Billing Networks and Processes,” authored by Dr. Yuval Lirov and planned for publication in 2024. We will post more chapters on this blog soon.

Share This

149 Responses

  1. I hardly leave a response, but i did a feew
    searching andd wound up here The Network Effect – ClinicMind.
    Andd I actually do have a couple of questions for
    you if you don’t mind. Is it only me or does it look like a feww of
    the remarks lok like they are left by brain dead people?
    😛 And, if you are writing on additional places,
    I would like to keep up with anything fresh you have to post.

    Would you make a list of the complete urls of your communitty psges like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

  2. Undeniably consider that that you said. Your favourite justification appeared to be at the web the simplest
    factor to take note of. I say too you, I certainly get anmoyed while other
    folks consider issues that they plainly don’t
    recognise about. Yoou managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the
    entire thing without having side effect , other folks could take a signal.
    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  3. Hello! Someone in my Facebook group shared this websit with
    us so I came to look it over. I’m definiely enjoying
    the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this tto my followers!
    Excellent blog and wonderful style and design.

  4. Heya outstanding website! Does running a blog similar to this
    require a massive amount work? I have no knowledge of coding however I
    was hoping to start my own blog in the near
    future. Anyways, should you have any recommendations or techniques for new blog owners please share.
    I know this is offf subject neverftheless I just needed to ask.
    Thank you!

  5. Hello there, I discovered your site via Google even as looking for
    a similar subject, your website came up, it appears great.

    I’ve bookmarked it in myy google bookmarks.
    Hi there, simply became aoert to your blog via Google,and found that it’s really informative.
    I am going to be carefuyl for brussels. I’ll be grateful iif
    you happen to continue this in future. Lots of otherr folks will be benefited from your writing.

  6. Undeniably believe that wbich you stated. Your favorite justification seemed
    to be on the internet the simplest thing to be aware of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed whle people consider worries that hey
    just don’t kknow about. You managed to hit
    the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side-effects ,
    people can ake a signal. Willl probably be back to get more.

  7. I usually do not drop manyy remarks, however i did some
    searching annd wound up here The Network Effect – ClinicMind.
    And I actually do have a couple of questions for you if it’s allright.
    Could it be only mee or does it look as if like some of the responses look like left by brain dead
    visitors? 😛 And, if you are posting on additional online sites,
    I would like to follow anything new you have to post.

    Would yyou list of every one of your community sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

  8. Hi would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re using?
    I’m going to start my own blog soon but I’m having a had
    time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs
    and I’m looking for something unique. P.S My apologies forr being off-topic but I hhad to ask!

  9. Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this website.
    It’s simple, yet effective. A lot oof times it’s difficult
    to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal.
    I must say you have done a very good job with this.
    Additionally, the blog liads extremely fast for
    me on Internet explorer. Outstading Blog!

  10. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering iff you knew of
    anny widgets I couyld addd to my blog that automaticazlly tweet my
    newest twitter updates. I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and
    was hoping mayb you would have some experience with somethingg like this.
    Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading ykur blg and I loo forward to your new

  11. hello there and thank you for your ingo – I’ve certainly picked
    up anything new from right here. I did however expertise a
    few technical issues using this website, as I experienced to reload the site lots of times
    previous to I could geet it to load properly. I had been wondering
    if your web hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but sluggishh loading
    instances times will sometimes affect your placement in googe and can amage your high-quality score
    if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding
    this RSS to my email aand can look ouut for much more of your respective intriguing content.
    Ensure that you update this again very soon.

  12. I do not write many comments, however i did some searching and wound
    up here The Network Effect – ClinicMind. And
    I do have a couple of questions for you if you usually do not mind.
    Is itt just me or does it appear like a few of these responses come across like left by
    brain dead visitors? 😛 And, if youu are posting on other places, I would like to keep up with anything fresh you have to post.
    Would you list of all of your shared sitss like your Facewbook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

  13. Hello! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I’d figured I’d ask.
    Would you be interested in exchhanging links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa?
    My website addresses a lot of the same subjects as
    yours and I think wee could greatly benefit from eah other.
    If you’re intferested feel free to shoot me an e-mail.
    I loik forward to hraring from you! Fantastic blog by the way!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *